Connect with others who understand.

Sign up Log in
Resources
About MyCOPDTeam
Powered By
Real members of MyCOPDTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.

I Don't Think My Question Was Clear! I'm Wondering If Anyone Is Using A 3-in-one Inhaler, Ie, Bretri And Also Using Duoneb. Is It Safe?

A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question 💭
Walnut Creek, CA

My research tells me that one should never mix 2 different anticholinergics
I questioned my pulmo about this and she just shut me down and said that her patients haven't complained. Pharmacists say not to use 2 anticholinergics as well. I think I need to find a new doctor as this one doesn't like patients to ask questions. She said a few days ago that patients waste her time with questions. She sits with her face in her computer and tells us not to interrupt her because she will lose her… read more

3 days ago
View reactions
A MyCOPDTeam Member

Yes I do but I'm using Treleg y and Duoneb,, plus inhalor, works fine.

6 hours ago
A MyCOPDTeam Member

@AlicelRose If you do have Dr. Cheung, you will find that your first appt will be thorough and possibly some test will be ordered, which is good! Hopefully, it will work out for you. I'll stay with her until my next appt in April as I think it will be time for my PFT. I'd like to know where I stand before changing. Stay in touch.☺️

2 days ago
A MyCOPDTeam Member

Hi Kathie. Been busy.
The short answer - YES. The LONG answer: Anticholinergics (ACH) CAN BE dangerous when used in excess. My concerns about this were pooh-hooed under the rug every Time IT was mentioned before. I did my OWN Research too and came to the final conclusion: ACH-class medicines are found in many treatments, including respiratory and incontinence for example. ACHs work on the Central Nervous system, in our case to tamp down the Coughing reflex. (while Albuterol RELAXES the muscles to increase the size of the Breathing pathway).

Here's the math: the amount of ACH in just two 2 nebulizer treatments equal a whole month from the powder inhaler! My pharmacist couldn't answer the question about the "Cumulative BUILDUP" of ACH in our system either - but Google could: https://www.healthline.com/health/anticholinerg...

So here is the REAL 🚫 danger. There are ACH meds in many OTC products as well which are NOT scrutinized. We CAN control how much we are exposed to THEM and their affects. But I'm not gonna skip a NEBBY treatment (or let my doc cancel the Rx for it) knowing it comes in handy on a BAD day.

NOW, IF I COULD JUST REMEMBER WHERE I LEFT MY PUFFER YESTERDAY!

be Well. . and WELL informed.

Anticholinergics
Anticholinergics
4 hours ago (edited)
A MyCOPDTeam Member

@A MyCOPDTeam Member Thanks Dan, glad to have an answer from a patient! Trelegy has an anticholinergic so you're getting 2 different ones without any obvious side effects, that is great. Duoneb works so much better than albuterol alone.

4 hours ago
A MyCOPDTeam Member

Thanks @A MyCOPDTeam Member

2 days ago

Related content

View All

I'm Wondering If Anyone Else Has This Problem - My Voice Seems To Be Getting Hoarse During The Day And At Time, I Even Seem To Lose It.

A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question 💭
Port Hueneme, CA

Need An Inhaler

A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question 💭
Monteal

I'm Classed As A Stage 4, I'm On Spriva/Symbicort. I'm Told There's No Other Medication For Me, How True Is That Possibility?

A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question 💭
Shreveport, LA
Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
By joining, you accept our Terms of Use, and acknowledge our collection, sharing, and use of your data in accordance with our Health Data Policy and Privacy policies.Your privacy is our priority Lock Icon
Already a Member? Log in